As someone who was, ahem, once invited to give a speech at the Pro Football Hall of Fame about the evolution of NFL end zone dances, I feel like I should weigh in on two stories in today's local newspaper about on-field celebrations.
- A front-page story by Paul Tenorio examines the recent emphasis on toning down player celebrations in high school football. In particular, a "point of emphasis" memo from the National Federation of State High School Associations regarding Rule 9-5-1, which prohibits "any delayed, excessive or prolonged act by which a player attempts to focus attention upon himself."
- A second story in the sports section by Steve Yanda talks about an NCAA "point of emphasis" to crack down on excessive celebrations in college basketball, including "muscling up after a dunk."
In basketball, most post-scoring celebrations occur with the game clock running. So it seems like "excessive" celebrating is actually a competitive disadvantage. I don't see the benefit in stopping the game to penalize a team.
On the other hand, football celebrations usually take place with the clock stopped and thus have the potential to delay the game. Cracking down on that seems fair to me. I'd let them celebrate all they want, but at the risk of a delay-of-game penalty (which ought to be more than 5 yards, by the way).